sbkrivit

Dec 042011
 

[Ed: See follow-up story here: More Slides From Sept. 22 NASA LENR Innovation Forum. See Rossi Story Index here.]

On Sept. 22, NASA conducted a LENR Innovation Forum workshop at Glenn Research Center in Cleveland, Ohio. Speakers included NASA scientists Joseph Zawodny, Gustave Fralick, Michael Nelson, Jim Dunn and Dennis Bushnell and retired University of Illinois professor George Miley.

New Energy Times obtained three of the slide presentations under a FOIA request.

Zawodny Slides
Nelson Slides
Bushnell Slides

At the meeting, Bushnell, the chief scientist at NASA Langley, said that LENR has a strong potential for a new source of energy. He was optimistic about nickel powder LENR solutions.

“The temperature you can get out of [LENR] is interesting,” Bushnell said. “We’ve had to be careful [in our research in] terms of the energetics. I don’t think there is a power [limitation] problem.

“I think the problem now is of raw courage to look into something that is new. We’ve been fortunate to have a center director at Langley that has the courage to support us to do this. We’ve been at it for three or four years.

“The U.S. efforts on this, for reasons I don’t understand, haven’t gone to the Widom-Larsen theory. They also haven’t gone to try to understand the 18 years of hydrogen-nickel [work] with really superb intellectual content. We need to get off of the Pons-Fleischmann electrochemistry and get into flow systems.”

At the meeting, Bushnell also spoke about Andrea Rossi, the inventor of the Energy Catalyzer.

“We intend to core down on the Rossi stuff and find out what’s real and what’s not,” Bushnell said. “But Rossi’s business is hard to explain other than with some kind of LENR. The Rossi stuff is probably wholly Edisonian and not totally understood, which is an understatement. But we can probably understand it at some point.”

Bushnell failed to mention that NASA had already made attempts to perform due diligence on the Rossi device. Some of the people involved in those attempts were in attendance at this workshop.

In the timeline shown in Nelson’s slides, Nelson omitted the Sept. 5 and 6, 2011 Rossi device tests performed in Bologna for engineers representing Quantum Energy Technologies. NASA representatives were present both days.

One of the eye-witnesses, a former NASA staff member, saw problems from the moment they arrived there.

“Rossi changed the game totally.” the witness said. “From the test plan, the device, everything. There was nothing there that we had agreed on. He had a 30 liter reservoir in there and he wouldn’t even let us see what was in the box or weigh the box.”

The Sept. 5 demonstration was inconclusive; Rossi’s device sprang a leak. The Sept. 6 demonstration was inconclusive; there was no outflow of steam or water.

On the second day, when the former NASA staff member asked Rossi if his device had an internal reservoir, Rossi became enraged.  Quantum’s engineers left but NASA engineers offered to come back in a few days to give Rossi time to fix the flow. Rossi declined their offer. He said he was “too busy.”

Dec 012011
 

Dario Braga, the director of scientific research at the University of Bologna, has clarified several points regarding the university’s official relationship with Andrea Rossi, inventor of the Energy Catalyzer.

First, Braga has given New Energy Times a more precise timeframe for how long it will wait until Rossi activates the research contract to study his Energy Catalzyer. The research contract, which was signed six months ago, becomes active only when Rossi makes his first payment to the university.

Second, Braga explained why the university considers its scientists not to have “carried out” any E-Cat experiments and why they have only “attended as observers to E-Cat experiments.”

Braga told “7 Gold News TV Magazine” in Italy on Nov. 27 that the university will not wait much longer for Rossi to make the first payment.

“The Rossi contract must start soon; otherwise, the University of Bologna can withdraw from the contract,” Braga said. “It must be understood that the period can be a few weeks, maybe a few months, but for sure not years.”

http://newenergytimes.com/v2/images/BragaDario-IlRestoDelCArlino60.jpg
Dario Braga, Photo Courtesy Il Resto Del Carlino

New Energy Times asked Braga yesterday whether the university had set a specific deadline for the first payment.

“The deadline for this is mid-January, and, as far as I know, an extension is unlikely,” Braga wrote.

On Nov. 11, New Energy Times published a news report based on the Nov. 5 press release from the university, titled “E-CAT: UNIVERSITY OF BOLOGNA IS NOT INVOLVED.”

New Energy Times asked Braga yesterday for a clarification of the involvement of professor Giuseppe Levi, who organized the Jan. 14, 2011, press conference for and demonstration of Rossi’s device, wrote the press release for the event, performed calorimetric measurements for Rossi’s device, wrote and distributed a scientific report of his calorimetry, worked with Rossi to run another experiment on Feb. 10 for 18 hours, reported results of that experiment to the news media, and participated in another Rossi experiment on April 3, 2011.

New Energy Times also asked Braga for a clarification of the involvement of professor Mauro Villa and student David Bianchini, each of whom had written and distributed scientific reports on behalf of Rossi.

In a New Energy Times video interview, Rossi had stated that Bianchini was a professor at the university and that Rossi was paying Bianchini a consulting fee to take radiation measurements of Rossi’s device.

Braga explained the university’s perspective to New Energy Times today in an e-mail.

“Faculty of the University of Bologna are not part of the Rossi device evaluation until the university can start with its own experiments,” Braga wrote. “There is nothing we can do to prevent our scientists from attending outside demonstrations at a private location or to prevent them from providing their own opinions as researchers on a scientific experiment. These behaviors are not illicit and do not carry any formal or informal implication on the level of involvement of the University of Bologna on the matter.

“Bianchini is not an employee of our university but a student and should not have used the Department of Physics as his affiliation in writing the safety report. We are investigating this matter further. Professor Villa’s and professor Levi’s reports were circulated and prepared long before the contract between Rossi and the Department of Physics was actually signed and were for internal purposes. Once again, these reports do not carry any implication about the involvement of the University of Bologna in Rossi’s demonstrations.”

Nov 282011
 

Thomas Blakeslee, a writer and investor in alternative energy, contacted me two weeks ago with his concerns and critique about my news coverage of Andrea Rossi, inventor of the Energy Catalyzer. We exchanged several e-mails.

Unlike some Rossi fans, Blakeslee has expressed his point of view in detail and with sincerity.

Blakeslee has stated many points and expressed perspectives that I do not agree with. Blakeslee has made statements about Rossi and his device that appear to be unsupported by fact.

However, Blakeslee has not hidden behind an anonymous screen name, but instead, he has taken personal responsibility for his views and statements. I respect this. Our exchange is listed on this page.

Nov 272011
 

Andrea Rossi, inventor of the Energy Catalyzer, is gradually decreasing the magnitude of excess heat he claims is produced by his low-energy nuclear reaction-based device.

On Feb. 28, 2010, Sergio Focardi, a retired physics professor from the University of Bologna, along with inventor Rossi published “A New Energy Source From Nuclear Fusion” on Rossi’s blog called the “Journal of Nuclear Physics.” In their paper, they claim an energy gain of 213 times heat output compared with the electrical input.

On Jan. 14, 2011, in a press conference and demonstration coordinated by Giuseppe Levi, a physics professor from the University of Bologna, Rossi and Focardi made a claim of an energy gain of 30 times.

Focardi reiterated these claims in an interview with Italian magazine Panorama.

“[The Jan. 14, 2011 demo used a] starting energy of 1 kilowatt and later,” Focardi said. “After a few minutes [input went] down to 400 watts to produce useful energy gain of 14 Kw, 31 times higher than the electricity input.

“[But] 31 is not the maximum factor that we have obtained, in other experiments we have arrived at 200.”

On April 19, 2011, Mats Lewan, a journalist with Ny Teknik went to Bologna to perform his own measurements of the Rossi device.

Soon after, Rossi began to state that his device produced a six-fold energy gain.

On June 15, I interviewed Rossi on video (Video Part 4, 6:53).

“As you have seen yesterday, the E-cats that we produce now have an excess which is six times, an output which is six times the input,” Rossi said.

According to two people who attended a lecture by Sven Kullander on Nov. 23, Rossi is now starting to talk about even smaller energy gains, the same level of energy production scientifically demonstrated and reported by Focardi when he previously worked with biophysicist Francesco Piantelli.

According to Patrik Lind, who attended the Kullander lecture, Kullander said that Rossi told him that his device now “works without a catalyst.”

According to Hampus Ericsson, who also attended the Kullander lecture, Kullander’s message was that “you could get a small effect without any catalyst, just like Focardi did in his 1994 paper.”

Nov 262011
 

On Nov. 23, Marina Amaduzzi of Corriere di Bologna published a story on Andrea Rossi, inventor of the Energy Catalyzer.

According to the news story, the University of Bologna department of physics and Rossi have signed a research contract that aims to replicate Rossi’s experiment.

This is not news and it is misleading. The contract was signed half a year ago. The contract is not active and will not become active until Rossi makes the first payment.

New Energy Times contacted Paolo Capiluppi, the head of University of Bologna physics department, on Nov. 16.

**********
Nov. 16, 2011
To: Simona Storchi; Paolo Capiluppi
From: Steven Krivit
Subject: Media Inquiry: Rossi

Dear Professor Capiluppi,

Is UNIBO still willing to accept payment from EFA Srl (Andrea Rossi’s Italian company) and activate the contract?

Grazie,
Steven
**********
Nov. 16, 2011
To: Steven Krivit, Simona Storchi
Subject: Media Inquiry: Rossi

Dear Steven,

UNIBO is still willing to activate the contract, and we are willing to accept payment from EFA.

Regards
Paolo Capiluppi
**********

New Energy Times is providing a brief timeline and a listing of related events below. We are fully aware of the inconsistencies made by some of the sources.

Timeline and Related Events:
Jan. 11, 2011 – University of Bologna Professor Giuseppe Levi writes and distributes press release for Rossi’s Jan. 14, 2011 press conference and demonstration.

Jan. 14, 2011 – Levi organizes press conference and conducts Rossi Energy Catalyzer demonstration. Levi performs “Test 2” with the involvement of other University of Bologna professors.

Jan. 21, 2011 – University of Bologna professors Levi and Bianchini publish reports on their test of Rossi’s Jan. 14, 2011 demonstration.

Jan. 26, 2011 – University of Bologna professor Mauro Villa publishes report on his test of Rossi’s Jan. 14, 2011 demonstration.

Feb. 10-11, 2011 – Rossi, Levi and Passerini perform sub-boiling test on Ross’s device.

Feb. 23, 2011 – Mats Lewan of Ny Teknik writes: “In the morning of February 10, the inventor and engineer Andrea Rossi initiated a new controlled experiment in Bologna…With him was the physicist and researcher Giuseppe Levi from the University of Bologna, who also supervised the public demonstration in January. Together they ran the unit for 18 hours.”

March 10, 2011 – Lewan writes that Rossi “is now paying 500,000 Euros to the Physics Department of Bologna University, following a new agreement.”

“End of May” – Paolo Capiluppi, the head of University of Bologna Physics Department, signs contract with Rossi’s company.  (Source: Capiluppi)

June 14, 2011  – Levi states on Krivit video that he wrote Rossi’s Jan. 11, 2011 press release (Video Part 2, 2:38). Levi also states: “it was revised by our department director because it is a press release of the department of physics…it was released as an official communication of our physics department. Our director, Professor Capiluppi, was always informed of what was going on, and also professor Zoccoli was present and he is actually the director of INFN section of Bologna, National Institute of Nuclear Physics. He was also informed.”

June 14, 2011  – Rossi states on Krivit video: “He is Professor Bianchini of the University of Bologna. He is the specialist, the expert specialized in measuring the radiations. He is the scientist that we have hired as a consultant to measure the radiation out of our reactors.”

June 21, 2011 – Rossi countersigns contract.

June 28, 2011 – New Energy Times publishes “Report #2 – Energy Catalyzer: Scientific Communication and Ethics Issues ”

June 29, 2011 – Capiluppi publishes official notice about the Rossi contract. (Notice is incorrectly backdated as June 19.)

Aug. 2, 2011 – Capiluppi tells New Energy Times that his backdating error was a “stupid mistype.”

Nov. 5, 2011 – University of Bologna issues a press release and denies that any of its faculty were involved with Rossi: “the only reason why the University of Bologna researchers attended as observers to E-Cat experiments.” [Typo is in original text.]

Nov. 11, 2011 – Storchi tells New Energy Times that the Nov. 5, 2011 press release was written by Dario Braga, the vice president for research and Paolo Capiluppi, the head of the physics department.

© 2025 newenergytimes.net